Edutaining Kids .COM                        2009 Holiday Gift Guides for Kids
Guide to Children's Products for Fun & Learning

 

Book Review:    The Giving Tree

Related Links
 

Classic. This simple, moving children's book by Shel Silverstein has opened up plenty of debates, both over its meaning and its appropriateness for children! The story features a boy and an apple tree. When he is young, the boy loves to eat the tree's apples, swing on the tree, and sit at its side. He even carves a heart on the tree, with the initials, "Me + T". 

The years pass, and the boy grows into adolescence, carving a new heart above the original one, with the initials of his presumed girlfriend. More years pass, and the boy returns to the tree. Although the tree offers him a swing and an apple to eat, the boy (now a young man) claims he is more interested in making money. The tree gracefully offers him her apples to sell in the market. Later, the "boy" revisits her, and the tree, quite eager to make him happy, offers him her branches to build a home for his wife and children. Later, the boy returns (now in midlife), claiming he needs a boat, and the tree offers her trunk! Years later, the boy is now quite aged, and he returns to the apple tree, now a mere stump. The tree cannot imagine that she has anything left to offer the "boy", but since he is too old to do much else, he uses the stump to rest--and the tree "is happy".

The intent and meaning of this book has "stumped" many over the years. Some find The Giving Tree to be a sad tale of codependency--about a tree that doesn't stop giving, and a boy who doesn't stop taking. I tend to think of the book as a story about the unconditional love a parent gives a child--the parent gives what he/she can, fully aware (and mostly happy) that the child will grow to be independent of the parent. The boy/man clearly develops a life of his own. This in itself is not sad. However, that the tree is reduced to a stump is not exactly fun; and, that the boy only appreciates the tree near the end of his life is indeed sad! The story can be viewed as one that makes people stop to think. A gentle lesson about appreciation can be pulled from the story, and it's a lesson that is subtle enough that, if picked up, can be all the more powerful simply because it was never force-fed. 

No matter how you look at it, the book is certainly a conversation piece. Controversy aside, the illustrations are simple line drawings that are effective enough that they could easily tell the story without ever reading the text.  

Written and illustrated by Shel Silverstein. The book is available in a hardcover edition that retails for approximately $15.99 US.

[For more information, user reviews, or to buy: The Giving Tree at Amazon.com]

Pros:
  • A powerful story whose meaning is left open to interpretation.

 

Cons:
  • The theme of the book is considered by some to be too sad/disturbing for children.

Back to Book Guide

Published: 1986 By: Harper Collins Juvenile Books Ages 6-up  
 

 

Our Rating:

A-

To Buy this book:
Buy The Giving Tree at Amazon.com
Buy The Giving Tree at Amazon.ca

 

 
Reviewed August 2002   Comments? Email us.
 

Guides to:  SoftwareVideos - DVDsBooksToysMusic,  & Video Games
Guides by Age:  ToddlersPreschoolersKids 5-8Kids 9-up, Families
Index to All Reviews    Index to All Articles
Shopping Guide   Family Internet Guide

What's New   Contact Us   About Us   Search
EdutainingKids.com Main