Edutaining Kids .COM                        2015-2016 Holiday Gift Guides for Kids
Parents' Guide to Children's Products for Fun & Learning


Children's Video Game Review:

Sims 2: Castaway (Available for the Nintendo DS, Wii, Playstation 2, and PSP)

Video Game Review: Sims 2 Castaway
Children's Video Game for PSP

By Electronic Arts

Our Recommended Age: Ages 12-up

Released: 2008

Our Rating: B+

about our reviews:
All reviews at Edutaining Kids are independent and impartial. Our children's video game reviews are designed to help parents and caregivers find the right games for their kids. Evaluations and ratings are based on educational and entertainment value, age appropriate content, and innovativeness.

Review for PSP - Sims 2: Castaway

Sims 2: Castaway is yet another version of the popular strategy game from Maxis. The storyline is both brilliant and simple. A group of sight-seeing tourists are stranded on a deserted island after a storm sinks their ship. Most players, clearly of a younger generation, liken Sims 2: Castaway to the television show "Lost" or Tom Hanks' movie Castaway. Players over thirty immediately recognize this as a video game version of "Gilligan's Island", right down to creating things from coconuts.

The graphics are familiar to anyone who has played a Sims game before: more than adequate, if a bit rough and at times choppy. Visibility can be a problem as the camera angle moves, and some of the special objects aren't so much difficult to collect as hard to find due to poor visibility. Options in creating your Sims crew members are moderately varied, however the graphics aren't clear and detailed enough to use the options to best effect. One Sim will look pretty much like the next, only with a different hair color. Even so, the graphics have a familiar Sims feel to them and are more than enough to assist the game along.

Game play is significantly different from other Sims games. Collecting and managing friends is a big part of play in Sims. Sims 2: Castaway still has a social motive which needs to be filled, but players spend much more of their time concerned with locating and gathering resources. This is half the fun. In Sims 2: Castaway, players get to fish, climb palm trees, hack through bamboo stands with stone machetes and dive for clams. Resources thus accumulated are then used to build bigger and better mouse traps - actually, fish traps, plus huts for shelter, assorted furnishings, stoves on which to cook and small watercraft to provide transport to and from the game's islands. By far the biggest portion of game play is spent collecting resources with which to maintain and improve the characters' survival.

The player's Sims characters still have motives which must be filled in order to keep the Sim happy, just like in the other Sims games. Amusingly, players fill social motives early in the game by making chummy with chimps, or imaginary friends built from sand and coconuts. Later in play the Sim will meet up with the rest of their crew members - players can make up to six Sims per game - but those are the only people on the islands. The Sims can't sleep out in the weather so players must build shelters, lest their Sim drop from exhaustion when a hurricane blows through the game's island chain.

The Sims' inability to sleep with rain driving in their faces is part of the goofy "realism" which adds one more fun layer to the game play. The clothes a character is wearing when shipwrecked tear and fall apart with time and exertion, and must be replaced with clothing made on the island from materials at hand. A character who doesn't replace their clothes will wear nothing but ragged loincloth-like remnants after a time. Men grow impressively shaggy beards and hair, which can be styled back to a more civilized look.

The game has a few frustrating aspects. The load screen which pops up as a Sim travels from one part of the island to the next is cute the first few times, but after that it's simply tiresome and takes too long. The game has a tendency to freeze in the midst of play, and if it doesn't resume on its own then players must simply restart from their last save, potentially losing lots of play. A Sim character can also just lock up. The other characters will obey directions as normal but the frozen Sim will neither move nor follow commands, not even to eat. Eventually the frozen Sim starves to death. The set-up for a new game takes far too long, akin to watching a slow web page load up.

Sims 2: Castaway is a refreshing take on the Sims franchise, and fun both on its own merits and when compared to more traditional Sims strategy games. Despite the flaws in the system, and a lack of depth, Sims 2: Castaway earns four out of five stars for fantastic game play.




  • Fun game for teens.
  • Fantastic gameplay.
  • Reasonably challenging.


  • Freezing, some long cut scenes.
  • Lack of depth


Our Rating:


more information:

For more information, user reviews, or to buy: The Sims 2: Castaway

Reviewed: February 2009

Comments? Email us

Other Guides, Reviews, & Articles at Edutaining Kids:

see also:

Gift Guides for Kids 9-up

Fun & Learning with Digital Cameras



The Sims 2: Castaway

Amazon's Holiday Toy List

Guides to:  SoftwareVideos - DVDsBooksToysMusic,  & Video Games
Guides by Age:  ToddlersPreschoolersKids 5-8Kids 9-up, Families
Index to All Reviews    Index to All Articles
Shopping Guide   Family Internet Guide

What's New   Contact Us   About Us   Search Main